Lexington’s delivery game is a crowded field, and sorting it out requires a system. You can get a Chicago-style pie that travels with its structural integrity intact, or you can gamble on a smushed pepperoni from a place that ignores your gate code.

The range here stretches from a historic church serving deep dish to an ice cream shop that outdelivers half the pizzerias in town. We ranked them all, including the burrito place that should be avoided at all costs.

The proof is in the box. Here is the definitive list.

Joe Bologna's Restaurant

Highlights
Historic church-turned-pizzeria
Iconic breadsticks with meals
Both deep dish and thin crust
Friendly, attentive service
Fun, worn-in atmosphere

Joe Bologna's operates out of an old church, and the building still feels like one. The dining room is worn in the way that only decades of loyal customers can manage. The deep dish is substantial, but the thin crust deserves equal attention. The breadsticks arrive with every meal, and they are not optional. They are the benchmark. Service is attentive without hovering, and the whole place hums with an easy rhythm. It is not the fastest delivery in town, but the food travels well. If you want pizza with history attached, this is the address. The atmosphere is fun in a slightly creaky way, and that is exactly right.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Frankfort.

Pearl's Pizza

Highlights
Bagels outperform the pizza
Seafood starters worth ordering
Rotating specials always deliver
Cozy spot for date night
Natural wine pairs well

Pearl's Pizza is a study in priorities. The bagels are better than the pizza. That is not an insult; it is a fact. The seafood starters, particularly anything involving shrimp, are worth ordering on their own. The rotating specials keep the menu alive, and they have never once disappointed. The space is compact, which makes it a solid date night option if you can get a table. The natural wine list pairs unexpectedly well with both the bagels and the pizza. If you go in expecting a pizza joint, you will leave confused. Go in expecting a neighborhood kitchen with good taste, and you will leave satisfied.

You might also want to check out the best bbq restaurants in Lexington.

South of Wrigley

Highlights
Authentic Chicago-style fare delivered
Beef rivals Portillo's quality
Polish sausage with caramelized onions
Crispy fries, rich cheese sauce

South of Wrigley delivers Chicago-style food that does not pretend to be anything else. The beef sandwich rivals Portillo's, and that is not a comparison I make lightly. The Polish sausage comes with caramelized onions, which is how it should be done. The fries are crisp, and the cheese sauce is rich enough to stand on its own. The pizza is not the headline here, but it holds its own. Delivery is reliable, and the food arrives hot. If you want a taste of the South Side without leaving Lexington, this is the place. It is a straightforward operation, and that is its strength.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Jeffersonville.

Crank & Boom Craft Ice Cream (Manchester)

Highlights
Best ice cream in Lexington
Flights of unique flavors
Strawberry balsamic sorbet standout
Friendly staff recommendations
Indoor and outdoor seating

Crank & Boom is technically an ice cream shop, but it delivers, and that matters. The ice cream is the best in Lexington, full stop. The flights let you sample multiple flavors, and the strawberry balsamic sorbet is the standout. The staff offers recommendations that are actually useful. There is indoor and outdoor seating, but delivery means you can eat it at home, which is often better. This is not a pizza review, but this list is about the best delivery in Lexington, and Crank & Boom deserves a spot. The product is consistent, and the service is friendly. It is a simple operation done exceptionally well.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Madison.

El Charro

Highlights
Best tacos in town
Owners are genuinely kind
Large, affordable portions

El Charro makes the best tacos in town. That is a bold claim, but the proof is in the delivery bag. The portions are large, and the prices are fair. The owners are genuinely kind, which shows up in the way the food is packed and the way they handle orders. The tacos travel well, which is more than I can say for many places. The carne asada is solid, and the al pastor has a proper char. This is not a pizza place, but it is part of the larger delivery conversation. If you need a break from dough and cheese, El Charro delivers a reliable alternative.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Berea.

La Bonne Vie Personal Chef + Catering

Highlights
Personal chef dining experience
Accommodates vegan dietary needs
Beautifully plated, generous portions
Interactive chef’s table brunch

La Bonne Vie is a personal chef service that also delivers. The experience is different from a standard restaurant order. The meal arrives beautifully plated, and the portions are generous. They accommodate vegan dietary needs without making you feel like a problem. The chef's table brunch is interactive, but the delivery option works just as well for a quiet night in. The food is thoughtful and precise. It is not fast food, and it does not pretend to be. If you want a meal that feels considered, this is the route. The price reflects the quality, and the quality is high.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Florence.

girlsgirlsgirls Burritos

Highlights
Terrible burritos, skip them
Great for catering parties
Fun, friendly food truck staff
Weak margaritas, poor meat quality
Retro decor, not worth it

girlsgirlsgirls Burritos is a hard pass. The burritos are bad. The meat quality is poor, and the margaritas are weak. The retro decor is trying too hard, and the food does not back it up. The only positive is the staff, who are friendly and fun. The operation works better as a catering option for parties, where the food is secondary to the event. For delivery, skip it. There are too many better options in Lexington. This is not a pizza place, but if it were, it would be the kind that disappoints. I would rather eat a delivery pizza from a gas station.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Williamstown.

Delish Pizza

Highlights
Fresh ingredients, perfectly cooked crust
Fast, hot delivery every time
Owner deeply invested in service
Spotless restaurant, friendly staff
Affordable prices, broad menu variety

Delish Pizza is the reliable workhorse of Lexington delivery. The crust is perfectly cooked, and the ingredients taste fresh. Every order I have placed arrived fast and hot. The owner is clearly invested in service, and it shows. The restaurant is spotless, and the staff is friendly. Prices are affordable, and the menu covers a broad range. This is not an adventurous choice, but it is a smart one. The pizza is consistent, and consistency is worth a lot in the delivery game. If you want a no-surprises pizza that arrives on time, this is it. I have never been disappointed, and that is rare.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Middletown.

Rosati's Pizza

Highlights
Chicago-style crust stays crisp
Marinara sauce among the best
Monster pizza packs fresh toppings
Owner personally ensures quality
Beer, wine, and mixed drinks

Rosati's delivers Chicago-style pizza that stays true to its roots. The crust keeps its crisp even after travel, which is a feat. The marinara is among the best I have had in Lexington, with a brightness that cuts through the cheese. The monster pizza is loaded with fresh toppings, and the quality holds. The owner personally checks orders, which is a level of care you do not often see. They also sell beer, wine, and mixed drinks, which helps. The delivery is not the fastest, but the food is worth the wait. If you want deep dish or thin crust, Rosati's handles both with competence.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Midway.

Big City Pizza Lexington (Chinoe)

Highlights
Fast, accommodating, and delicious
Top-five pizza in memory
Crispy pepperoni, doughy crust
Delivery can arrive smushed
Door instructions often ignored

Big City Pizza at Chinoe is fast, accommodating, and delicious. I put it in my top five pizzas in memory. The pepperoni comes out crispy, and the crust has a doughy chew that works. The problem is the delivery. The pizza can arrive smushed, and the door instructions are often ignored. That is frustrating because the product is excellent. The staff is polite, and the turnaround time is quick. If you can pick it up, do that. If you must rely on delivery, be prepared to reshape your slices. The taste is worth the hassle, but the hassle is real.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Lexington.

Stoner's Pizza Joint

Highlights
Cheesy, generous portions
Fast delivery service
Beats major chains
Worth the wait
Sincere family operation

Stoner's Pizza Joint is cheesy and generous. The portions are large, and the delivery is fast. It beats the major chains without trying too hard. The service has a sincere, family-operated feel that comes through in the bag. The wait can be a little longer on weekends, but the food justifies it. The crust is not the best in town, but it is competent. The toppings are plentiful, and the cheese pull is real. This is a dependable option that does not pretend to be gourmet. It is pizza for people who want pizza. I have ordered here multiple times, and it has yet to fail.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Erlanger.

PieTana

Highlights
Fabulous food, great atmosphere
Attentive service from Sam
Creative drink substitutions handled well
Unique salads with asparagus
Outdoor seating available

PieTana has fabulous food and a great atmosphere, even for delivery. The service from Sam is attentive, and creative substitutions are handled without complaint. The salads are unique, with asparagus appearing in ways you would not expect. The pizza is solid, and the outdoor seating is a plus if you dine in. Delivery is prompt, and the packaging keeps everything intact. The menu is not the largest, but each item is executed well. If you want a meal that feels a step above standard delivery, PieTana delivers. The flavors are bold, and the staff clearly cares about the outcome.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Simpsonville.