Frankfort doesn’t reward the impatient. This is a town where a Saturday morning bourbon barrel cheese run at the farmers market counts as prep work, and where the best pie might legally be a personal chef’s side project.

The search for pizza here swings between extremes: a sourdough crust from Locals that snaps with authority on one end, and a dependable hoagie-adjacent slice from Linney’s on the other. We ate through the lot—including a sushi bar that has no business being this memorable.

Skip the online reservation traps and read carefully. The list is the map.

Serafini

Highlights
Book direct for reservations
Service excellent from start
Pasta bolognese stands out
Food amazing, highly recommended
Call to bypass online limits

Serafini operates less like a restaurant and more like a well-kept secret that happens to serve dinner. The moment you call to book directly, bypassing whatever online limitation tries to contain you, you understand the game. Service is excellent from start, a rarity in this town where good hospitality often evaporates by the second course. The pasta bolognese stands out, rich and unapologetic. But the pizza? It arrives with a crust that snaps, a sauce that hums. The food is amazing, and I recommend you commit to this place early. Ignore the online limits; pick up the phone. You will not regret the effort.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Lexington.

La Bonne Vie Personal Chef + Catering

Highlights
Memorable 80th birthday dinner
Vegan options handled gracefully
Beautiful plating, generous portions
Brunch series worth repeating
Two skilled chefs, one team

La Bonne Vie runs like a two-chef operation with a single-minded mission on the table and in the room. At an 80th birthday dinner I attended, the plating arrived beautiful, the portions substantial, and the staff moved with a quiet precision that made the entire evening feel considered. They handled a vegan request gracefully, no eye roll, no compromise in flavor. I have not yet experienced their brunch series, but the reputation is already solid among those who have. Two skilled chefs, one team, no tavern pretension. What they lack in flash they make up for with consistency. For a pizza reviewer, it is a curious detour, but one worth taking for the crust edges.

You might also want to check out the best food in Florence.

Franklin County Farmers Market

Highlights
Great Saturday morning stop
Fresh produce and baked goods
Awesome bourbon barrel cheese
Local meats and crafts
Worth a visit anytime

The Franklin County Farmers Market is not a pizzeria, but on a Saturday morning it performs close to one if you count anything edible. Great fresh produce and baked goods greet you the moment the rain holds off. The bourbon barrel cheese, that one item I will drive across town for, sits somewhere between a dairy necessity and a local landmark. Local meats and crafts crowd the tables. My wife calls it the only Saturday stop you can trust. The pizza logic here is simpler: buy the ingredients, take them home, preheat your oven, and chase what the market cannot give you: a twenty-minute bake time.

You might also want to check out the best wings in Lexington.

Downtown Frankfort Inc

Highlights
Quaint small-town charm
Distinctive local businesses
Historic distilleries nearby
Capitol-area artisan bread
Daniel Boone’s resting view

Downtown Frankfort Inc does not make pizza, yet it roots the entire survey. The quaint small-town charm appears in its walkable blocks, where distinctive local businesses keep the pulse. Historic distilleries push their vapors nearby, and the capitol-area artisan bread, though not pizza, helps you recognize which standards matter. The view of Daniel Boone's resting place quietly insists you respect the land. I find myself walking here before hitting the pizzerias on this list, calibrating a no-nonsense palate. The town reminds you where you are: a place where pizza has to work harder to be stylish.

You might also want to check out the best goodwill in Lexington.

Omakase Sushi & Sake Bar @Chevy Chase

Highlights
Consistently fresh, superior fish quality
Warm service, welcoming each visit
Toro melts in your mouth
Omakase set worth returning for

Omakase Sushi & Sake Bar, a pizza writer's guilty detour, still commands a liver. The fish is consistently superior, fresh enough that even a skeptical reviewer pauses. Toro melts on your tongue, and the warm service wraps the whole room in a welcome. The omakase set deserves a repeat visit; this is a bar that understands decisión. If you expect pizza here, you will be disappointed. If you accept the craft, the evening works. I come here with a little more intent than when I cross a pizzeria threshold, but that is the point: this is Frankfort, and your options travel both directions.

You might also want to check out the best sports bar in Lexington.

Buddy's Pizza

Highlights
Fresh toppings and crispy crust
Friendly staff, attentive service
Quality outweighs the wait
Worth returning for variety

Buddy's Pizza carries the weight of being a local chain that has built a reputation on reliability. The fresh toppings are visible, and the crust arrives with a proper crunch. Friendly staff and attentive service set the entire meal right, though they will tell you the wait can be part of the experience. Quality outweighs the delay, most nights. I ordered the variety tray and found each slice held its own flag. It is not the wildest taste in town, but it is the kind of pizza you remember when you need a weeknight solution, and that memory serves you.

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Lexington.

DaVinci's Pizza

Highlights
Quality worth every penny
Crust earns its keep
Toppings piled generously
New favorite in Frankfort
Sauce needs bolder flavor

DaVinci's makes a bold argument for the premium side of Frankfort. The quality is present and you will pay to see it, but the expense feels earned. The crust earns its keep, with a structure that holds toppings without collapsing. Toppings appear piled generously, an exercise in heavy dabs and overlapping surfaces. The sauce though, undermines the confidence. It lacks a bolder, saltier, more acidic bite to cut through the cheese. Do I call it a new favorite? I take the piece halfway. Then I order the second slice, because the crust is correct, and the compensation arrives. The sauce needs work.

You might also want to check out the best lawyer in Lexington.

Locals Food Hub & Pizza Pub

Highlights
Sourdough crust cooked perfectly
Best tomato sauce ever
Fresh, delicious signature pies
Friendly, attentive staff
Local provisions and outdoor seating

Locals Food Hub & Pizza Pub provides the clearest answer to the question Frankfort often does not ask. The sourdough crust emerges from the oven perfectly done: crisp edges, airy interior, tang that does not give in to the crust. The tomato sauce may be the best I have had inside a Frankfort pizza slice; it arrives with an acidity that snaps. The signature pies stay fresh, the ingredients sourced from what they call local provisions. Friendly staff manage the room while outside seating lets you track the weather. I deliberate over every bite. This is where I go when I no longer need a chase.

You might also want to check out the best divorce lawyers in Lexington.

Limewater

Highlights
Eclectic menu, top-notch service
Fresh ingredients, simple preparation
Historical property near Buffalo Trace

Limewater sits on a historical property near Buffalo Trace, but it makes a separate claim. The menu is eclectic, which in a certain writer's vocabulary means you cannot guess the next item. The service arrives top-notch and brisk. Fresh ingredients meet simple preparation, which usually works. Their pizza does not make the best-of list, but the experience of eating there, within view of the distillery, shifts your mood. Go at the right hour and you will leave with a sense of grace that a standard slice cannot give. Do not expect the crust to beat Locals, but expect the room to linger.

You might also want to check out the best places to live in Lexington.

Linney's Pizza

Highlights
Amazing pizza hoagie
Perfectly cooked mozzarella sticks
Attentive, polite staff
Spotless 100% health rating
Inviting, fresh aroma inside

Linney's Pizza greets you with an unmistakable fresh aroma that signals they have their baking station first. The pizza hoagie, that intermingling of sandwich and pizza, is a public service announcement. Mozzarella sticks arrive perfectly cooked, golden and pull-worthy. The staff is attentive, polite, and the whole operation maintains a spotless 100% health score, not a small thing. It is the best kind of no-nonsense place, a pizza that does not try to impress you with story, only with execution. When I need to trust a room completely, this is the address.

You might also want to check out the best dry cleaner in Lexington.

Pizza Inn

Highlights
Ideal for sizable birthday parties
Hot, fresh whole pies
Clean game room with arcade
Attentive drink and table service
Spotless bathrooms and salad bar

Pizza Inn is the logical answer for anyone hosting a sizable birthday party in Frankfort. Hot, fresh whole pies come from the kitchen in even movements, and the clean game room with an arcade keeps the younger set occupied in a windowless behind-the-strip sense. Attentive staff refills drinks, clears plates, and confirms the salad bar stands spotless. You are not here for a revelation in dough; you are here for a reliable feast after a session of tokens. The bathroom and salad bar at the same standard tells you the owners respect routine. It does not press boundaries, but it extends a hand that works.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artist in Lexington.

POURter's

Highlights
Welcoming, attentive, consistent service
Cozy venue with family-friendly touches
Awesome bar snacks, affordable prices
Great food truck burger, inviting vibe

POURter's feels like your neighbor decided to run a bar and remembered that everyone still wants a pizza now and then. The service is welcoming, attentive, consistent, with that edge of humor that blue collar bars practice. The venue is cozy, family-friendly even, with bar snacks that outshine the price point. There is a food truck on some nights that serves a burger that is genuinely good, which proves the venue knows how to host, not just cook. The pizza is not the central act, but it holds the fort. I sit with the crowd, and the evening settles into the right quotient of cheesecrust beer instead.

You might also want to check out the best food in Georgetown.