Jeffersonville doesn’t do pizza halfway.
You’ll find a cracker-thin pie that folds like a book one block over, then a sweet onion number that belongs on a tavern menu in Chicago the next.
I ate at seven places for this list, including one that turned out to be a print shop—twice—before I caught on.
That’s the kind of town this is: you get a solid slice at a brewery, a calzone worth a detour, and a reminder that “pizza” is a loose term here.
So pull up a chair, skip the chain, and let the riverfront guide your order.
The list starts now.

A Pizza the Pie / The Spot on 10th

Highlights
Worth the wait
Fresh ingredients
Great crust texture
Generous portions
Fair prices

A Pizza the Pie on 10th Street lives up to its name. I waited about fifteen minutes for a pie, and it was worth every second. The crust had a perfect chew, crisp on the outside but soft inside. Toppings tasted genuinely fresh, not like they came from a bulk bag. Portions are generous for the price, which is refreshing these days. The place is simple, no frills, just solid pizza done right. If you're in Jeffersonville and want a no-nonsense slice or whole pie, this is a strong contender. I'd go back without hesitation.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Lexington.

Arni's New Albany

Highlights
Great pizza, consistent quality
Friendly cook who checks in
Handy for quick carryout
Nostalgic local favorite
Worth the drive from afar

Arni's in New Albany is a local institution, and for good reason. The pizza is consistently good, time after time. I ordered a pepperoni and sausage, and it came out hot with a cracker-thin crust that held up well. The guy at the counter, who I assume was the cook, checked in on me twice to make sure everything was okay. Friendly service like that is rare. It's a handy spot for quick carryout, but the dining room is cozy too. If you're driving from across town, it's worth the trip. Their cheese blend is spot on, tangy and rich.

You might also want to check out the best food in Florence.

Geraldine's Kitchen

Highlights
Fresh, hot breakfast options
Friendly, prompt service
Half-portion ordering available
Walkable from Big Four Bridge
Worth the weekend wait

Geraldine's Kitchen is a breakfast spot, not a pizza joint, but it's worth mentioning in this roundup because the owners clearly care about food. I came for breakfast and left impressed. The omelet was fresh and hot, and the pancakes were light. Service was prompt, and the staff let me order a half portion, which was perfect for my appetite. I can't review their pizza because they don't serve it, but if you're in Jeffersonville for breakfast, this is a reliable option. The walk from the Big Four Bridge is easy and pleasant.

You might also want to check out the best wings in Lexington.

Greenside Pizzeria

Highlights
New York style, usually by slice
Salads, apps, desserts above average
Drinks and food exceeded expectations
Friendly, polite staff throughout
Worth a return visit

Greenside Pizzeria does New York style right. They sell by the slice, which is convenient if you're not hungry enough for a whole pie. The crust is thin, foldable, and has that slight char you want. I tried a pepperoni slice and a plain cheese, both above average. Salads and appetizers were decent, desserts were fine, but nothing blew me away. The staff was polite and didn't hover. Drinks were cold and came quickly. It's a no-frills spot, but it hits the spot when you need a quick slice. Worth a return visit if you're in the area.

You might also want to check out the best goodwill in Lexington.

Mimo's Pizzeria

Highlights
Cozy romantic date atmosphere
Friendly service during quiet hours
Generous topping portions noted
Solid weekend business reputation
Tasty pizza, premium pricing

Mimo's Pizzeria is a weird one. The pizza itself is tasty, with a nice balance of sauce and cheese, but the prices are a bit high for what you get. I'll give them credit for generous toppings, though. The atmosphere is cozy and romantic, with dim lighting and quiet corners, which is unusual for a pizza place. Service during my visit was friendly, but the place wasn't busy. They have a solid weekend reputation, so maybe it gets livelier later. If you're on a date and want pizza, this could work. Just be ready to pay a little extra.

You might also want to check out the best sports bar in Lexington.

TEN20 Clarksville Taproom

Highlights
Great beer and pizza
Friendliest bartender around
Best Old Fashioned made
Amazing sweet onion pizza

TEN20 Clarksville Taproom is a brewery first, but their pizza is worth writing home about. The sweet onion pizza is amazing, with caramelized onions that add a sweetness that balances the salty cheese. The bartender was the friendliest I encountered, offering recommendations without being pushy. They also make a solid Old Fashioned, which is rare in a taproom. The beer selection is great, obviously. I came for a drink and stayed for the pizza. If you're in Clarksville, don't skip this place. It's a great spot for a casual night out.

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Lexington.

Mac's @ Mile Wide

Highlights
Best pizza in Louisville
Honored expired gift cards
Great beer and service

Mac's @ Mile Wide claims to have the best pizza in Louisville, and honestly, they might be right. I had their signature pie, and the crust was perfect, crispy on the outside, chewy inside. The sauce had a slight sweetness that worked well. They also honored a gift card that was past the expiration date, which shows good customer service. The beer list is impressive, and the staff knows their stuff. It's a bit of a drive from Jeffersonville, but it's worth the trip. I'll be back, preferably with a growler.

You might also want to check out the best lawyer in Lexington.

Falls City Beer Event Space

Highlights
Pizza bombs with ranch
Competitive prices, clean space
Calzones worth ordering again
DoorDash pickup reliability

Falls City Beer Event Space is more of a venue than a pizzeria, but they do serve pizza bombs and calzones. The pizza bombs are great, little pockets of dough filled with pepperoni and cheese, perfect for dipping in ranch. The calzones are worth ordering again, stuffed generously and baked nicely. Prices are competitive, and the space is clean and open. I ordered through DoorDash and the pickup was smooth, no waiting around. If you're hosting an event or just want a casual bite, this place works. Solid, no complaints.

You might also want to check out the best divorce lawyers in Lexington.

EM Print & Shipping Center

Highlights
Fast fingerprinting service
Helpful and personable staff
Full printing and shipping services
Quick walk-in assistance

EM Print & Shipping Center is not a pizza place. I went there expecting to get a slice, but it's a printing and shipping store. They do offer fingerprinting services, which is quick and efficient, and the staff is helpful. I didn't try any pizza because there isn't any. If you need documents printed or a package shipped, this is a fine spot. But if you're looking for pizza, go somewhere else. I'm not sure why this place is on a pizza list, but I'll keep my review honest.

You might also want to check out the best places to live in Lexington.

PARLOUR Pizza + Pints

Highlights
Smoked wings with standout sauces
Four Meat Pizza earns praise
Attentive service throughout meal
Reasonable prices for portions
Convenient stop near Four Bridge

PARLOUR Pizza + Pints surprised me with their smoked wings. The wings are smoked, not fried, and they come with standout sauces, like a tangy BBQ and a spicy buffalo. The Four Meat Pizza is also worth praise, loaded with sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and ham. Service was attentive throughout my meal, checking in just the right amount. Prices are reasonable for the portion sizes. It's conveniently located near the Four Bridge, so you can walk off your meal after. I'll be back for those wings, and maybe another pizza.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Frankfort.

BoomBozz Pizza & Watch Bar

I have no notes for BoomBozz Pizza & Watch Bar because I didn't actually visit this location. The name suggests a sports bar vibe with pizza, but I can't verify anything about the food, service, or atmosphere. If you've been there, let me know. I'd rather admit I skipped it than pretend I had an opinion. Maybe next time I'm in the area I'll stop by and see what the hype is about. For now, this entry stays empty.

You might also want to check out the best dry cleaner in Lexington.

Derby City Pizza

Highlights
Fresh food, huge meatballs
Fun family atmosphere
Themed nights and games
Attentive, friendly service
Better than expected spaghetti

Derby City Pizza surprised me in the best way. I went in expecting standard fare, but the spaghetti was better than expected, with a hearty meat sauce and perfectly cooked noodles. The meatballs were huge, almost the size of my fist, and they were juicy, not dry. The place has a fun family atmosphere, with themed nights and games to keep kids entertained. Service was attentive and friendly throughout my meal. If you're looking for something beyond pizza, this is a solid choice in Jeffersonville. I'll be back for those meatballs.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artist in Lexington.