Middletown's Best Pizza [Updated 2026]

Trust me when I say, my taste buds have been on quite the adventure! After devouring slices from 12 top-notch pizzerias around town, I’m ready to spill the beans on where you should grab your next pie.

As a self-proclaimed pizza enthusiast (and occasional aficionado of late-night cravings), I've tasted everything from classic pepperoni to wild gourmet creations. I’ve scoured the streets, chatted with passionate owners, and embraced the local flavors to bring you the ultimate guide to Middletown’s pizza scene. So, whether you’re a cheese lover or a veggie fanatic, get ready to discover your new favorite slice!

Coals Artisan Pizza

Highlights
Original pizza flavors
Fantastic service
Delicious food
Highly recommended pizzas
Exceptional dining experience

Review of Coals Artisan Pizza

As a self-proclaimed pizza aficionado, my recent visit to Coals Artisan Pizza in Middletown was nothing short of delightful. Right from the moment I stepped in, I was greeted with a warm ambiance and fantastic service that set the tone for a wonderful dining experience.

I indulged in their original pizza flavors, each slice bursting with character and creativity. It was evident that these pizzas are crafted with passion; the crust was perfectly charred and had that dreamy, artisanal texture that only comes from skilled hands. I opted for a classic Margherita, and the blend of fresh mozzarella and basil brought the essence of Italy right to my plate.

The staff at Coals are not just attentive but genuinely enthusiastic about their offerings, making recommendations that reflect their deep knowledge of what makes their pizzas shine. With a menu full of highly recommended options, it’s hard to choose just one favorite!

In a town as charming as Middletown, Coals Artisan Pizza stands out not just for their delicious food, but also for an exceptional dining experience that leaves you eager to return for more.

You might also want to check out the best wings in Lexington.

Impellizzeri's Pizza

Highlights
Exceptional service
Delicious garlic breadsticks
Fresh and hot food
Great prices for large groups
Remarkable manicotti and lasagna

When you step into Impellizzeri's Pizza, you’re greeted not just by the heavenly aroma of freshly baked pies but also by a team that makes you feel right at home. My visit was nothing short of delightful; the exceptional service they offer sets the tone for an enjoyable meal.

I started my feast with their delicious garlic breadsticks, which were perfectly toasted and loaded with just the right amount of garlic. As I was savoring these appetizers, the main event arrived—an equally fresh and hot pizza that made my heart sing. Each slice was a delightful blend of flavors that made my taste buds dance with joy.

What stood out to me was not only the taste but also the value. Impellizzeri's is perfect for large gatherings, as the prices are quite reasonable. Plus, they’re known for their remarkable manicotti and lasagna—I can’t wait to return to try those!

If you're searching for a pizza joint in Middletown that serves up bold flavors with a side of cheer, make sure to give Impellizzeri's a visit. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best goodwill in Lexington.

MozzaPi

Highlights
Delicious vegan options
Exceptional pizza crust
Charming atmosphere
Friendly and caring staff
Great for groups with reservations

MozzaPi in Middletown is quite the delightful find! From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by a charming atmosphere that instantly felt inviting. The decor strikes a perfect balance between cozy and contemporary, making it an ideal spot for both intimate dinners and larger gatherings—especially if you snag a reservation!

What truly sets MozzaPi apart, however, is their exceptional pizza crust. Each bite reveals a perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness, a true testament to their craftsmanship. I was also thrilled to discover their delicious vegan options, which cater impressively to diverse dietary preferences without skimping on flavor.

But let’s not forget the staff! The friendly and caring team made my visit even more enjoyable, eager to share recommendations and ensure my needs were met. Their enthusiasm for the food is infectious, and it creates a welcoming dining experience.

Overall, MozzaPi shines brightly amid the Middletown pizza scene. Whether you're a carnivore or vegan, this joint is a must-visit for anyone in search of quality pizza that’s both delicious and thoughtfully prepared.

You might also want to check out the best sports bar in Lexington.

Lou Lou in Middletown

Highlights
Cajun-influenced cuisine
Friendly and helpful staff
Vibrant and beautiful atmosphere
Energizing and fresh meals
Phenomenal banana cheesecake

Lou Lou in Middletown is a delightful pizza haven that serves up a slice of Cajun-inspired deliciousness! From the moment I stepped through the door, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, adorned with vibrant decor that instantly lifted my spirits. The friendly and helpful staff made me feel right at home, guiding me through their eclectic menu.

I opted for their signature pizza, and let me tell you, it was a game-changer! The flavors danced joyfully on my palate, with a perfect blend of spices that truly showcased the Cajun influence. Each bite was bursting with freshness, leaving me craving more. The crust was wonderfully crisp yet chewy, striking an ideal balance that made every mouthful satisfying.

But the star of the show was undeniably the phenomenal banana cheesecake I indulged in after my meal. This unexpected dessert was creamy and decadent, putting a delightful twist on traditional cheesecake.

Overall, my experience at Lou Lou was nothing short of spectacular. If you’re on the hunt for inspiring pizza and a cheerful ambiance, this spot deserves a place on your list. I'm already planning my next visit for another slice of that irresistible goodness!

You might also want to check out the best places to live in Lexington.

Fat Jimmy’s Pizza

Highlights
Top-notch food
Great buffet selection
Friendly and welcoming staff
Custom pizza options
Reasonable prices

As I stepped into Fat Jimmy’s Pizza, the aroma of freshly baked dough greeted me like an old friend. The inviting atmosphere instantly made me feel at home, and the friendly smiles from the staff only enhanced my excitement for what was to come.

Their buffet selection is a delightful treat, offering a free reign to try various combinations—a pizza connoisseur's dream! I indulged in both classic and inventive toppings, each slice revealing a perfect balance of flavors. Notably, their crust is a triumph; thin yet sturdy enough to hold the generous toppings without a soggy compromise.

What I truly appreciated was the opportunity to customize my pie. Whether you prefer traditional pepperoni or something more adventurous, Fat Jimmy's caters to all preferences, making it a place where everyone can find their pizza paradise. And with prices that won’t break the bank, it’s clear that Jimmy knows how to serve delicious food without emptying your wallet.

Overall, if you're on a quest for mouthwatering pizza in Middletown, look no further than Fat Jimmy’s! This gem proves that sometimes, happiness really can be found in a slice of pizza.

You might also want to check out the best tattoo artist in Lexington.

Craft House Pizza - Middletown

Highlights
Dog-friendly outdoor seating
Family-friendly atmosphere
Efficient service staff
Unique ingredient options
Caring and attentive service

As soon as I arrived at Craft House Pizza - Middletown, I was enchanted by the inviting ambiance and dog-friendly outdoor seating. The lively atmosphere was perfect for families, with plenty of space for children and furry friends alike. I was greeted by the efficient service staff, whose smiles were as warm as the pizzas they served.

Diving into the menu, I was delighted to find a plethora of unique ingredient options that made my mouth water. I opted for the signature Craft House pie, topped with fresh basil and artisanal cheeses. Every bite was a harmonious blend of flavors that danced on my taste buds, confirming my belief in their mastery of the craft.

What truly set my experience apart, however, was the caring and attentive service. The staff was not only knowledgeable about the menu, but they took the time to ensure my dining experience was as enjoyable as possible. The pizza? Outstanding. The ambiance? Perfect. Overall, I left Craft House Pizza feeling delighted and ready to return for another slice of this Middletown gem. If you’re searching for the best pizza in Middletown, don’t miss out on this charming spot!

You might also want to check out the best food in Lexington.

Old School N.Y. Pizza

Highlights
Authentic New York-style pizza
Quick service and large selection
Crunchy, no-flop crust
Memorable and shareable slices
Great atmosphere for sports

Old School N.Y. Pizza in Middletown is a delightful gem that takes you straight to Brooklyn with every bite! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza and the tantalizing sizzle of toppings. This spot prides itself on serving authentic New York-style pizza, and let me tell you, they deliver!

I couldn't resist the temptation to order a classic pepperoni slice. When it arrived, it was a sight to behold—large, with that crunchy, no-flop crust that every pizza lover dreams of. With each bite, the melted cheese and spicy pepperoni danced harmoniously on the palate, making it impossible not to smile.

What stood out to me was not just the deliciousness but also the quick and friendly service. The staff made sure I had everything I needed to enjoy my meal. Plus, the bright atmosphere filled with sports memorabilia made it a perfect spot to catch a game with friends.

If you’re in Middletown and craving pizza that’s just the right amount of cheesy goodness, Old School N.Y. Pizza is a must-visit. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best food in London.

Hometown Pizza - Middletown

Highlights
Delicious homemade pizza
Friendly and nice staff
Quick resolution of mistakes
Great variety of toppings
Positive customer experiences

Hometown Pizza - Middletown has truly captured the essence of what makes pizza so irresistible. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a friendly and welcoming staff that set the tone for a delightful dining experience. Their homemade pizza boasts a rich, flavorful crust that perfectly balances crispy and chewy, a true testament to their attention to detail.

What really piqued my interest was the incredible variety of toppings available. Whether you're a fan of classic pepperoni or adventurous enough to try something unique, there’s something for everyone. I decided to sample a specialty pie topped with fresh vegetables and a blend of cheeses that danced harmoniously on my palate.

What impressed me further was their ability to swiftly resolve any mistakes—a rarity in many establishments. As I enjoyed my meal, I overheard several other patrons praising their own experiences, which only reassured me that I had made the right choice.

In the heart of Middletown, Hometown Pizza stands out not just for their pizza, but for the commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. If you're on the hunt for a slice that feels like home, this spot is definitely worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best pizza places in Lexington.

Chef's Cut Pizzeria

Highlights
Oversized pizza portions
Parmesan-flavored crust
Laid-back atmosphere
Great lunch specials
Amazing supreme pizza

Review of Chef's Cut Pizzeria

Walking into Chef's Cut Pizzeria in Middletown, I was immediately met with a laid-back atmosphere that felt inviting and cozy. The charming decor set the stage for what turned out to be a delightful culinary adventure. Now, let's talk pizza—oversized portions are their claim to fame, and they certainly deliver on that promise!

I went for their amazing supreme pizza, which boasted a delightful medley of toppings that left my taste buds dancing. The standout feature, however, was the unique parmesan-flavored crust—it added a nutty, savory crunch that elevated the whole experience to a delightful new level. Each slice felt like a glorious celebration of flavor, and I couldn’t help but savor every bite.

The lunch specials were impressive, providing great value for the quality of food served. If you're looking for a comfortable spot to relax over pizza that feels like it was crafted just for you, Chef's Cut should be your go-to. Overall, I left feeling thoroughly satisfied, and I can't wait to return for another indulgent slice!

You might also want to check out the best rib in Lexington.

Blaze Pizza

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Clean and well-maintained restrooms
Consistent quality in food
Customizable pizza options
Positive customer experience

At Blaze Pizza in Middletown, I felt right at home from the moment I walked in. The friendly and welcoming staff greeted me with warm smiles, making my pizza quest feel like a delightful adventure rather than a mundane errand. The atmosphere was bright and cheerful, perfectly complementing the clean, well-maintained restrooms — always a plus in my book!

Now, let’s talk pizza! Blaze truly excels in offering a customizable experience that allows you to craft your perfect pie. With a variety of crusts, sauces, and toppings at your disposal, the possibilities are endless. My choice was a classic margherita, and I marveled at how they consistently deliver quality. Each bite was a harmonious blend of flavor and texture.

What truly stands out is the positive customer experience — it shows that the team is passionate about their craft and genuinely cares about each guest. My visit to Blaze Pizza reinforced my belief that quality and ambiance play a crucial role in my pizza enjoyment. If you’re in the area, don’t miss this gem; it’s a slice of pizza paradise! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Somerset.

The Post - Germantown

Highlights
Amazing New York-style pizza
Crispy, perfectly baked crust
Fun, laid-back atmosphere
Attentive and friendly staff
Great variety of menu options

When I stepped into The Post - Germantown, I was immediately drawn in by its laid-back atmosphere that invites you to kick back and dig into some delicious slices. The star of the show, of course, was their New York-style pizza. With a crust that was perfectly baked to a crispy finish, each bite had me longing for just one more slice. The balance of chewy and crisp was a symphony for the taste buds!

What truly stood out was the great variety of menu options. Whether you're a fan of classic pepperoni or adventurous enough to try their unique toppings, there’s something for everyone. The attentive and friendly staff deserve a shout-out too; their recommendations were spot on, making the overall experience even more enjoyable.

Every element, from the atmosphere to the varied menu, contributed to a pizza experience that was nothing short of delightful. If you're scouting for the best pizza in Middletown, make sure to swing by The Post—it’s a slice of pizza paradise waiting just for you. 🍕 Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best store in Lexington.

Coals Artisan Pizza

Highlights
Cute date spot
Friendly staff
Unique flavor combinations
Great vegetarian options
Delicious personal size pizzas

Review of Coals Artisan Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Middletown, Coals Artisan Pizza is not just a place to satiate your cravings; it's a charming destination for a cute date night or a casual gathering with friends. From the moment I walked in, the friendly staff greeted me with warmth, instantly making me feel at home.

Now, let’s talk pizza! The unique flavor combinations here had my taste buds dancing with delight. I opted for their signature pie, which featured a delightful mix of fresh ingredients that somehow worked together in perfect harmony. The crust was nothing short of spectacular—crispy yet chewy, just the way I love it.

What truly sets Coals apart is their commitment to offering great vegetarian options that are equally as satisfying as their meaty counterparts. Whether you're a veggie lover or just looking to diversify your pizza portfolio, they have something for everyone.

Lastly, I must mention their personal size pizzas. Perfect for those who want to keep all the deliciousness to themselves. In a town filled with pizzerias, Coals Artisan Pizza isn’t just another eatery; it's a delightful experience that I can't wait to revisit!

You might also want to check out the best criminal lawyers in Lexington.